When a failed water heater is an emergency
A slow drip at the base of a tank is a warning. A steady stream is an emergency. Once the steel tank corrodes through, water follows the floor drain or the nearest low spot, and a 40 to 50 gallon tank can empty in the time it takes to find the shutoff valve.
No hot water in January is its own kind of urgent, especially with children or older relatives in the home. If you are unsure whether the problem is a repair or a full replacement, our page on water heater repair explains how we tell the two apart.
Do this before the plumber arrives
- Switch the breaker off for an electric heater, or turn the gas control to off for a gas heater.
- Close the cold water supply valve on the pipe entering the top of the tank.
- Open one hot tap upstairs to relieve pressure, and move stored items off the floor around the heater.
- If you smell gas, leave the house and call the gas utility or 911 from outside. Do not flip switches.
Repair or replace: how to decide
Tank water heaters wear out from the inside. Sediment settles, the anode rod is consumed, and the steel starts to rust. As a rough guide, tanks start to fail in the range of 8 to 12 years, and the date stamped on the serial label tells you where yours stands.
| Situation | Usual answer | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Leak from the tank body | Replace | A corroded tank cannot be patched safely. |
| Leak at a pipe fitting or valve | Often repair | The tank is still sound. |
| Unit under about 6 years with no heat | Often repair | Elements, thermostats and gas valves are replaceable. |
| Unit past 10 years with repeated repairs | Replace | Each repair buys little time. |
| Rust-colored hot water only | Inspect first | Could be the tank or the home's old pipes. |
Not sure which side of that table you are on? Call us and describe what you see.
Call (301) 936-0389Questions to settle before the new unit goes in
A good replacement starts with a few answers. How many people use hot water at the same time in the morning, where will the discharge pipe run, and is the gas line or electric circuit sized for the new model? Settling these first avoids a second visit and a surprise on the invoice.
- Do you want the same fuel type or a change from gas to electric?
- Is there a floor drain near the heater, or does the pan need a drain line?
- Are the shutoff valves on the water lines old and stiff?
- Do you plan to sell soon, in which case a documented new unit helps?
What drives the price of a replacement
What replacement day looks like in a Rockville home
We drain and disconnect the old unit, set the new one on a proper drain pan, and reconnect water, gas or electric, and the relief valve with discharge piping. Then we fill the tank, purge air, light or power it, and check combustion and venting on gas models before we leave.
Permit and inspection rules for plumbing in Montgomery County run through WSSC Water, so we confirm what your job needs before we begin. If you are choosing between a tank and a modern on-demand unit, read about tankless water heaters first, and if your heater is simply the wrong size for your family, our team can also handle a planned water heater installation.
Rockville homes and water heaters
Some older houses have compact utility spaces where only certain tanks fit, so measure the space before you choose a unit. Newer King Farm and Fallsgrove homes are a different era of construction. What this means for you is simple: the right replacement depends on the room it has to fit, not only on the number of bathrooms.
Rockville also treats most of its own drinking water from the Potomac River, with WSSC Water serving the rest of the city. We do not quote a hardness figure because the city's report does not list one, so ask your utility or test your tap if you want to know how fast scale may build up inside your tank. A flush every year helps either way. If you are in a nearby town, see our Gaithersburg plumbing page.
Where this comes from. According to Montgomery County's permit guidance, plumbing permits are handled through WSSC Water, which has its own Plumbing and Fuel Gas Code. Check with WSSC Water for what your job needs, because rules change.
Water Heater Replacement questions from Rockville homeowners
Yes. Call to ask what help is available for your address.
A straightforward tank swap usually takes a few hours once the new unit is on site. Venting changes, gas line work or tight access add time, and we tell you before we start.
It depends on your gas line, venting and household size. Tankless units cost more up front and need a properly sized gas supply, so we look at your setup first.
Policies differ. Many cover sudden water damage but not the failed appliance itself. Check with your insurer and keep photos of the leak.
